This article is my comment (response) to Cathy's post "Buy Pilipino".

(An excerpt) by F. Sionil Jose's Why are Filipinos So Poor.

In the ’50s and ’60s, the Philippines was the most envied country in Southeast Asia. What happened?

What did South Korea look like after the Korean War in 1953? Battered, poor - but look at Korea now. In the Fifties, the traffic in Taipei was composed of bicycles and army trucks, the streets flanked by tile-roofed low buildings. Jakarta was a giant village and Kuala Lumpur a small village surrounded by jungle and rubber plantations. Bangkok was criss-crossed with canals, the tallest structure was the Wat Arun, the Temple of the Sun, and it dominated the city’s skyline. Ricefields all the way from Don Muang airport — then a huddle of galvanized iron-roofed bodegas, to the Victory monument.Visit these cities today and weep — for they are more beautiful, cleaner and prosperous than Manila..In the Fifties and Sixties [the Philippines] was the most envied country in Southeast Asia. Remember when Indonesia got its independence in 1949 it had only 114 university graduates compared with the hundreds of Ph.D.'s that were already in our universities. Why then were we left behind?The economic explanation is simple. We did not produce cheaper and better products.

The basic question really is why we did not modernize fast enough and thereby doomed our people to poverty. This is the harsh truth about us today. Just consider these: some 15 years ago a survey showed that half of all grade school pupils dropped out after grade 5 because they had no money to continue schooling.Thousands of young adults today are therefore unable to find jobs. Our natural resources have been ravaged and they are not renewable. Our tremendous population increase eats up all of our economic gains. There is hunger in this country now; our poorest eat only once a day.But this physical poverty is really not as serious as the greater poverty that afflicts us and this is the poverty of the spirit.

Why then are we poor? More than ten years ago, James Fallows, editor of the Atlantic Monthly, came to the Philippines and wrote about our damaged culture which, he asserted, impeded our development. Many disagreed with him but I do find a great deal of truth in his analysis.

This is not to say that I blame our social and moral malaise on colonialism alone. But we did inherit from Spain a social system and elite that, on purpose, exploited the masses. Then, too, in the Iberian peninsula, to work with one's hands is frowned upon and we inherited that vice as well. Colonialism by foreigners may no longer be what it was, but we are now a colony of our own elite.

We are poor because we are poor -- this is not a tautology. The culture of poverty is self-perpetuating. We are poor because our people are lazy. I pass by a slum area every morning - dozens of adults do nothing but idle, gossip and drink. We do not save. Look at the Japanese and how they save in spite of the fact that the interest given them by their banks is so little. They work very hard too.

We are great show-offs. Look at our women, how overdressed, over-coiffed they are, and Imelda epitomizes that extravagance. Look at our men, their manicured nails, their personal jewelry, their diamond rings. Yabang - that is what we are, and all that money expended on status symbols, on yabang. How much better if it were channeled into production.

We are poor because our nationalism is inward looking. Under its guise we protect inefficient industries and monopolies.

And finally, we are poor because we have lost our ethical moorings. We condone cronyism and corruption and we don't ostracize or punish the crooks in our midst. Both cronyism and corruption are wasteful but we allow their practice because our loyalty is to family or friend, not to the larger good.

I am not looking for a foreign power for us to challenge. But we have a real and insidious enemy that we must vanquish, and this enemy is worse than the intransigence of any foreign power. WE ARE OUR OWN ENEMY. And we must have the courage, the will, to change ourselves.


On September 30, 2008 at 1:35 AM , iceah said...

love the way you choose your pics c: mang kulas pabili nga ng tsinelas.... c: know that song by yano?

On September 30, 2008 at 8:47 AM , Cathy said...

Hi e-souled,

Thanks for the comment. Of course you are right about us being poor because we have no pride in being Filipinos. That said, if I would be given superpowers, I will try to educate all of our countrymen about being proud of our country.

Unfortunately, all I can do is blog ,make theories and write essays about how rotten our system is. What I want to propose is a way of how you and me and other normal Filipinos can do something that doesn't involve superpowers.

We can all make our country better by doing as little as buying a Filipino-made sandal instead of a Birkenstock.

On September 30, 2008 at 7:26 PM , e-souled said...

Lol, thanks iceah! but mind you that's not havaianas! during the late 90's!?

On September 30, 2008 at 8:27 PM , e-souled said...

hi cath!

Thanks for the comment. Last night i watched a documentary about Korea's success.And i aboslutely agree with you! Each one of us in our own little way can do something to make our country better!

Like the "Saemaul Undong" of Korea (New Village Movement) Saemaul Undong began in 1970 as a major state-run rural-development campaign under president Park Chung Hee.

Saemaul Undong was Korea’s big government-led plan of modernizing the countryside. At that time, fast industrialization had created a huge gap between urban and rural area, and something had to be done. Koreans couldn’t address the problem better. Huge infrastructure expenditure in the rural area made use of excessive supply in building material industry, improved welfare of rural people, fostered civic participation, calmed down unrest, and created new domestic demand. The government planed the basic infrastructure, but also provides funding and building material for projects drawn up by villagers themselves, which is exactly what we now call public-private partnership.

Source:Development Bank Research Bulletin

On October 1, 2008 at 2:02 AM , pchi said...


thank you for the comment on my post.

so we know more than 60% of Filipinos are poor

what's next?

what are the steps we should do... ?

I think the reproduction issue is also partly to be blamed

If Filipinos don't have many children, at least they could have educated their children

I agree with you, the Spanish influence was not good

their siesta, maƱana habit... etc are still in our culture

so, as Filipino's what are the steps we need to take to help our country?

Anong magagawa mo para sa bayan mo?

On October 2, 2008 at 5:24 PM , e-souled said...

pchi thanks for the comment.

i also read your post ”Pilipino: Anong magagawa mo para sa bayan mo?”

I agree with you! Each one of us in our own little way can do something to make our country better!

Huwag kang mag alala napakadami pang mga Pilipino ang nag mamahal sa bansa natin. at ang bawat isa ay kailangan lang gawin ano man ang kanyang paraan para makatulong sa pag angat ng bansa!